I used to think tape was, well, tape. Just grab whatever roll you have at home and slap it on a box. But after having packages pop open during shipping (and dealing with the mess that followed), I learned the hard way that not all tape is created equal. The type of tape you use can make the difference between a box arriving neatly sealed or falling apart halfway through its journey.
In this guide, I’ll break down the different types of packing tape, explain which ones actually hold up during shipping, and share a few options that work best for USPS, FedEx, and UPS.
Types of Packing Tape
When you walk into a store or scroll through Amazon, the tape aisle can be overwhelming. Here are the most common types you’ll run into and what they’re actually good for:
Clear Shipping Tape
This is the standard stuff you see at post offices and on most shipped boxes. It’s strong, sticks well to cardboard, and is designed to handle the stress of shipping. If you’re mailing everyday packages, this is usually your best bet.
Water-Activated Tape (Gummed Tape)
This tape is a favorite for heavy-duty shipping. You need to moisten the adhesive before applying, but once it sticks, it bonds to the cardboard like glue. Many businesses use it because it’s tamper-proof and incredibly secure.
Duct Tape
As strong as it looks, duct tape is actually a bad choice for shipping. It doesn’t bond well to cardboard over time, especially in different temperatures, and most couriers like USPS specifically recommend not using it.
Masking Tape or Painter’s Tape
These are designed for short-term use, not shipping. They peel off easily and won’t hold a box together through handling, so skip them for mailing packages.
Strapping Tape
This is reinforced with fibers, making it extremely strong. It’s often used for heavy boxes or odd-shaped items that need extra support.
Which Tape Works Best for USPS, FedEx, and UPS
Each courier has its own recommendations, but they all agree on one thing — strong packing tape is a must.
USPS
USPS specifically advises against duct tape, masking tape, and string. They recommend clear or brown packing tape that’s at least two inches wide. Water-activated tape is also approved, especially for heavier boxes.
FedEx
FedEx suggests using pressure-sensitive plastic shipping tape, ideally between two and three inches wide. For heavy packages, they also approve water-activated tape because of its strong seal. Avoid masking and cellophane tapes, since they tend to peel off in transit.
UPS
UPS recommends pressure-sensitive plastic tape too, and like FedEx, they prefer rolls that are two to three inches wide. They also caution against using paper-based tapes unless they’re water-activated gummed tape, which is designed for heavy-duty shipping.
In short, all three carriers want you to use strong shipping tape — either standard packing tape or water-activated tape. Anything else risks your package being delayed, returned, or even refused at the counter.
When to Use Water-Activated Tape vs Regular Packing Tape
Both water-activated tape and regular packing tape can keep a package sealed, but each has its own strengths.
Water-Activated Tape
This is best for heavy boxes, valuable items, or anything being shipped long distances. Once applied, it bonds with the cardboard and is very hard to peel off without leaving damage. That makes it tamper-evident, which is why many e-commerce businesses use it. It’s also ideal for boxes that might go through rough handling since the seal holds up better under pressure.
Regular Packing Tape
This works well for most everyday shipments — things like clothes, books, small electronics, or lightweight household items. It’s quicker to apply, easier to find, and doesn’t require extra tools. For most people mailing through USPS, FedEx, or UPS, regular packing tape gets the job done.
The rule of thumb is simple: if your package is heavy or valuable, go with water-activated tape. If it’s light to medium weight, regular packing tape will work just fine.
Recommended Tapes
1. Scotch Heavy Duty Shipping Packing Tape — Clear, 6 Rolls (1.88 in × 54.6 yd)
Features & Why It’s Strong:
-
Clear plastic pressure-sensitive tape with industrial-strength, solvent-free adhesive.
-
Tough enough to stick on hard-to-adhere surfaces, like recycled cardboard.
-
Resists slivering, splitting, and tearing; one strip often enough over seams.
-
Comes in a 6-roll set; each roll is 1.88 inches wide × 54.6 yards long.
Pros:
-
Very strong hold; works well even for heavier packages or rough handling.
-
Clear appearance—looks neat, shows the printing on boxes if any.
-
One strip sealing requirement makes assembly quick.
-
Widely available and trusted brand (Scotch / 3M).
Cons:
-
Because it’s plastic tape, not biodegradable; more environmental impact.
-
Adhesion can weaken in super cold or extremely damp conditions.
-
Might need a good dispenser to cut cleanly; tearing by hand can be messy.
-
Slightly more expensive than basic tapes, especially in single-roll purchases.
2. TooCust Water Activated Tape (Fiber Reinforced Kraft Paper Tape, Brown) — 2″ × 165 ft per roll
Features & Why It’s Strong:
-
Kraft paper tape with water-activated adhesive; requires moistening before application.
-
Reinforced with fibers for extra tensile strength; better resistance against splitting under stress.
-
Writable surface (you can write on the tape) which helps for labeling.
-
Long roll length (165 ft) makes it cost-efficient for frequent shipping.
Pros:
-
Very strong and secure seal; the adhesive fuses with cardboard, making tampering evident.
-
More eco-friendly than many plastic tapes: kraft paper + starch adhesive is easier to recycle/less toxic.
-
Good under varied temperature / humidity conditions; less prone to peeling.
-
Reinforced version is excellent for heavy or bulky boxes.
Cons:
-
Need water or dispenser to activate adhesive; adds one more step in packing.
-
If stored improperly (too wet/humid), performance drops.
-
Application is slower than peel-off plastic tape; might be awkward if you need speed.
-
Brown color might show on boxes or contrast with some packaging aesthetics.
3. KAIY Strapping Tape Heavy-Duty Filament Reinforced
Features & Why It’s Strong:
-
Fiberglass filaments embedded in a clear backing makes the tape extremely strong under tension. Resists stretching, tearing, or splitting along seams.
-
Useful width & length: the ¾-inch width is narrower but good for reinforcing seams or strapping heavy packages. The long length (60 yds) gives good value for repeat use.
-
Moisture resistance helps it hold up better in damp or humid conditions compared with non-reinforced plastic tapes.
Pros:
-
Very high tensile strength — excellent for heavy, bulky boxes or reinforcing package bottoms & straps.
-
Clear backing lets you see any underlying labels/text without obstruction.
-
Doesn’t stretch much — more likely to break than stretch out like regular tapes.
-
Good durability in rough handling, temperature/humidity changes.
Cons:
-
Narrow width (¾-inch) means more strips needed across seams or flaps — slower to apply.
-
Because it’s reinforced, cutting it cleanly needs sharp scissors or a shear; tearing by hand is harder.
-
Not ideal for large surface sealing (e.g. full box top) — best used for reinforcement, not always substitute for broader tape.
-
More expensive per foot than simple clear packing tape due to reinforcement.
4. PERFECTAPE Heavy Duty Brown Packing Tape (6 Rolls)
Features & Why It’s Strong:
-
Traditional brown plastic packing tape that is thicker than the very basic kind; often used for moving, storage, shipping.
-
Comes in multiple rolls (6) so good for bulk and frequent use. Large total length makes it cost-effective.
-
Slightly matte brown finish helps hide dirt or scuff marks, gives a clean look for brown boxes.
Pros:
-
Affordable in bulk; good value when you ship regularly.
-
Strong enough for typical shipping; holds well over seams and box edges.
-
Brown tone blends well with kraft cardboard, looks more “packaged” in shipping contexts.
-
Easy to apply with standard plastic tape dispenser; cut clean edges.
Cons:
-
Not as strong as reinforced or filament tape or water-activated tape. More prone to peeling if edges are exposed or under tension.
-
Adhesion can degrade in very cold or humid environments.
-
Less eco-friendly (plastic base) than paper or kraft water-activated tapes.
-
Brown tape on lighter boxes or bright packaging may show contrast or look less tidy.
5. IPG 9341 Kraft Paper Flatback Premium Packing Tape
Features & Why It’s Strong:
-
Flatback kraft paper tape: paper backing with strong adhesive (often natural or resin types). It’s thicker, robust.
-
Excellent for heavy boxes, long-distance shipping, or when you want a more eco/aesthetic look. The kraft paper backing makes it recyclable with the box in many places.
-
Designed for extra heavy boxes (manufacturer claims up to ~70 lbs in some conditions) because of its Corrugrip Adhesive Technology.
Pros:
-
Eco-friendlier than plastic tapes; more recyclable especially in places with paper/cardboard recycling.
-
Strong seal and tamper-evidence: harder to peel off without tearing.
-
Good look on kraft boxes; gives more “professional” / industrial packaging feel.
-
Less noisy, generally more aesthetic, good for packaging boutique / branded shipments.
Cons:
-
Paper backing tears more easily if box edges are rough or if package is handled roughly. Requires care.
-
Adhesive may set slower and require firm pressing; not always as “instant grip” as high tack plastic tape.
-
More sensitive to moisture; if paper gets wet, adhesive effectiveness may drop.
-
Might require more tape width or additional strips to achieve same strength across large seams compared to reinforced plastic tapes.
| Product | Best Use Case | Strength Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Scotch Heavy Duty Shipping Packing Tape, Clear (6 rolls, 1.88″ × 54.6 yd) | Great all-round tape for everyday shipping; ideal for small to medium boxes you ship often. | Strong adhesive, resists tearing and splitting. Clear, looks clean. Requires a dispenser for best results. |
| TooCust Water Activated Tape (Fiber Reinforced Kraft, 2″ × 165 ft) | Best for heavy or valuable packages, or when you want a tamper-evident, secure seal. Also good if you ship frequently and want something eco-friendly. | Bonds deeply with cardboard; reinforced fibers give extra strength. Needs moistening (or dispenser). Slower to use. |
| KAIY Filament Strapping Tape (¾” × 60 yd) | Best for reinforcing seams, strapping heavy loads, or securing odd-shaped boxes. | Very high tensile strength (fiberglass filament). Narrow means you may need multiple strips. |
| PERFECTAPE Heavy Duty Brown Packing Tape (6 rolls) | Good value for frequent shipping; works well when appearance (brown box) matters. | Strong grip for regular shipping. Less robust than reinforced or paper-based tapes under extreme stress or weather. |
| IPG 9341 Kraft Paper Flatback Premium Packing Tape | Ideal when eco-friendliness and aesthetics matter (e.g. boutique or gift-style parcels), or for long-distance shipping where paper backing helps with recycling. | Excellent seal and strength. Paper backing is nice but can tear more easily; needs care. |
FAQs About Best Tapes for Mailing Packagese
Can I use duct tape to seal a package?
No. Even though duct tape feels strong, it doesn’t bond well with cardboard over time. USPS, FedEx, and UPS all specifically advise against it.
Is masking tape or painter’s tape okay for shipping?
Not at all. Those tapes are designed to peel off easily, so they won’t hold up during shipping. Your box could pop open in transit.
What’s the best tape for cold or humid conditions?
Water-activated kraft tape usually performs better than clear packing tape in extreme temperatures or humidity. It fuses with the cardboard and won’t peel off as easily.
Can I recycle boxes with packing tape on them?
Most recycling centers accept boxes with small amounts of plastic tape, but water-activated paper tape is much more eco-friendly since it can be recycled with the box.
What width of tape should I use?
Two inches is the minimum for mailing. Three inches is better for larger or heavier packages because it covers more surface area.
What’s the most cost-effective tape if I ship often?
Bulk rolls of clear shipping tape are budget-friendly for frequent shippers. If you send heavy boxes or run a small business, water-activated kraft tape is pricier upfront but saves money in the long run since you use less per box.
Do carriers reject packages if the wrong tape is used?
Yes. If you show up at USPS, UPS, or FedEx with a box sealed in duct tape or masking tape, they may refuse to accept it. Always use shipping-approved tape.
Conclusion
It’s easy to overlook tape when you’re sending a package, but the truth is, the wrong choice can make or break your shipment. Clear shipping tape works for most everyday boxes, while water-activated kraft tape is the gold standard for heavy or valuable shipments. Reinforced filament tape is perfect for extra support, and eco-friendly kraft options give your package a professional and sustainable finish.
The key is simple: match the tape to the job. If you’re mailing a light box, regular clear tape is fine. If it’s heavy or valuable, water-activated tape will give you peace of mind. And if presentation matters, paper tapes can be both strong and attractive. With the right tape, you don’t just seal a box — you make sure your package arrives the way you intended.